It’s funny, but until very recently I didn’t realize how cutthroat the “Pitching Instruction Arena” was. You’ve probably seen it, too. Google “baseball pitching tips” and you’ll get a hoard of different baseball Web sites and pitching philosophies. And, with that, you’ll get a smattering of different opinions on “proper pitching mechanics,” “proper conditioning programs,” and “proper throwing routines.”
Of course, this all makes it extremely difficult for coaches, parents and pitchers to decipher the proverbial wheat from the chaff… you know: the good stuff from the bad stuff.
In fact, the Pitching Instruction Arena in some venues is so cutthroat that I’m sometimes left with a not-so-good-feeling about being a pitcher. There’s nothing worse than reading something you hope to be informative about pitching, only to realize you’re getting beat up with one instructor’s gripe against another.
I’m sure you’ve seen this, too: You’ve got “Instructor A” taking potshots at “Instructor B’s” pitching philosophies, his mom, his wife and his kids. Then Instructor B swipes back at Instructor A with even more bickering. Maybe calls him “fat,” or a “loser.” It’s crazy. Before long, the pitching discussion – about actual pitching topics that could help you become better – is all but non-existent.
That, I’m afraid, is today’s Pitching Instruction Arena. Not good, right?
Well here’s something that I’ve strongly believed for some time. Maybe it’ll restore a little faith.
All of the top-pitching instructors (by “top,” I mean instructors with a proven track-record of a successful personal career and a successful coaching career) actually agree on about 95% of the same stuff.
I’ll say it again: most pitching instructors actually agree on about 95% about what it takes to become a successful, more complete pitcher.
It’s the %5-or-so where the differences occur. But if you have a FAQ-sheet on each instructor, you’d see that those differences are over some of the most minute aspects of pitching. So much so that it doesn’t really matter which philosophy you prescribe to – so long as the instructor is qualified.
I grew up a product of Bill Thurston’s pitching instruction. I worked with Thurston for more than seven years (1994-2001).
I was then coached by Major League Pitcher Mike Dunne, my pitching coach at Bradley University. I was then coached by more than one dozen other Major League pitchers and professional pitching coaches in collegiate summer-ball and in professional baseball. And you know what?
They all literally preached the same things.
Sure, they called it something different (the way a Texan speaks with a different accent than my New York accent), but all of the outstanding, top-level pitching instructors were teaching the same things.
So, where does that leave you? In a good spot, really! When looking for a professional pitching instructor to work with, take a look at his credentials, of course. Then maybe take a look at his success-rate. However, I’d also urge you to check out his personality. Ask yourself if you feel comfortable working with the guy…
Because from what I’ve read from some of the other instructors, I’d be hard-pressed to invite a lot of them over for dinner for fear that they might start ripping on my wife.
Yours in baseball,
Steven Ellis
The Complete Pitcher®
www.thecompletepitcher.com